When we first began thinking about favorite scenes for this episode (and the next), we wondered how we could pick “favorite” scenes from an episode replete with tragedy and torture. Upon careful consideration, however, we realized there are some things we enjoyed, apart from the brilliant performances by Sam Heughan, Caitriona Balfe, and Tobias Menzies. Regardless, we will not address the most brutal scenes. It is simply too hurtful.
Let us first address the obvious. Sam Heughan proved in this episode that he is worthy of any and all accolades and awards for his brilliant and heart-wrenching performance. Much of his acting was done without dialogue. Sam has mastered the art of communicating with his eyes and face to give us a wide range of emotions.
A picture is worth a thousand words.
Black Jack Randall burns Jamie’s Petition of Complaint, yet he gets no reaction from Jamie. That must have been a disappoint, since we know how BJR likes to evoke strong emotions from his victims.
BJR’s attempts at intimidation fail. He asks Jamie how he would prefer to die, and wants him to admit that he is terrified. If he admits to being terrified, BJR promises to give him an honorable death of his own choosing. (What a deal.) Still, Jamie doesn’t beg or surrender. He remains calm.
No matter what form of intimidation BJR employes, Jamie remains cool.
This is one of our favorite scenes because it illustrates the amazing acting talents of Sam Heughan. The tear rolling down his cheek breaks our hearts. Finally, after BJR threatens Claire’s life, Jamie surrenders himself. Claire is his Achilles Heel. The only weapon BJR has against Jamie.
Claire and Jamie sometimes make foolish decisions, but their bravery cannot be questioned. Jamie isn’t the only man to find Claire’s courage and bravery attractive.
Claire Fraser, “a most singular woman” (Dougal Mackenzie), “no coward,” and a “fit match for [her] husband” (Black Jack Randall). Yes, she is a quite extraordinary and “rare” (Jamie Fraser) woman, and we love her well.
One of the most satisfying scenes of the episode is when Claire tells BJR she curses him. She is no physical match for him. The only weapon she has in her arsenal is knowledge, and she wields it expertly. What a brilliant mind f**k.
We love it when Claire plays the witch card.